Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category
Oh, I’m you. How are fine?
Posted on: June 8, 2014
Since sometime last Fall, my life has been crazy. If I didn’t have my phone calendar to keep track of what appointments are when, I’d be totally lost. I mean, I do try to make sure I transfer all appointments to the big wall calendar at home, but the wall calendar doesn’t have an alarm that goes off a half hour before the event to remind me, “Ahem. You ARE remembering that you have an appointment at A:BC o’clock, right?” For most of February, and all of March, April, and May I had at least one appointment or scheduled necessary activity, if not two, and sometimes three, either for me, or my mom, or my cousin, almost every single day of every single week. June was looking a lot better, but that got turned on its head as well. Let me elucidate….
My daughter: I didn’t mention in the previous blog that Bethy ended up on a week of modified bedrest that first week of February because of premature labor. I was so booked up that I was only able to come over to help for one morning, I think. (She had plenty of other help, for which we were both thankful! She has many othermothers, and a flock of friends.) Early in the morning of February 13, my newest granddaughter, Rosalie Julia, made her grand entrance. For the next month, I helped when I could, but with all the medical crises of my two caregivees, it wasn’t as much as I’d have wished. Rosie’s sisters adore her. Stay tuned for once she starts crawling; that tune may change! Rosie is a smiley, smiley baby, and a total people-person, very interactive and talkative. I can hardly believe she’s almost four months already.
My mom: Since the February 8 post, it was determined that the brain tumor hadn’t grown at all and was, in fact, slightly smaller, if anything. The severe nausea abated, though she continues to have problems with milder, occasional nausea even now. She had bad problems with gas for a couple more months, the only relief for which proved to be ginger ale. She was prescribed lidocaine patches for her back pain. These help a lot, but are impossible for her to put on by herself, so she had to have the services of a health care aid friend. We ended up changing doctors, and bless the day we did. The new doc discovered that she has two collapsed vertebrae since all this started. She did finally resume the cancer drug at its lowest dose at the end of March, and has been able to tolerate the mild side effects. By early May, she had regained a lot of energy, and was back to doing 10 or 15 minute walks around her community, doing housework and gardening in short stretches, dressing in her normal skirts and blouses instead of easy-to-put-on sweats. Then two weeks ago, she suddenly lost all energy and was huffing and puffing as badly as she had when she first was diagnosed, so weak she could barely walk, and was somewhat incoherent in her thinking. Blood work revealed an elevated white blood cell count and a CT, pneumonia. (Bright side, it showed the lung tumor has shrunk some.) So that night they started her on a quinine-related antibiotic, levoquin. Emotionally, these last months have been extremely difficult (no duh, huh?). It’s hard being jacked this way and that, it’s good, it’s bad, maybe you’ll live for years, maybe you’ll be dead within months. Even with a strong faith, KNOWING the suffering that all but certainly lies ahead is not a pleasant prospect – and is hard not to think about. So she had asked for medication to help deal with the anxiety/depression. As it happened, they started her on Zoloft the day after starting the levoquin. That night about 10, she called me to tell me that she’d been hearing and seeing things that weren’t there since sometime mid-day! Into the ER. They immediately replaced the levoquin with a cephalosporin drug IV, and took her off Zoloft. Her white blood cell count was even higher than the previous day’s had been. A head CT the next day didn’t show any obvious reason for the hallucinations, so they were put down to a reaction to one/both/combination of the drugs. She stopped seeing things by the end of that day, and hearing things by the next morning, and since her white blood cell count had come down significantly, too, she was allowed to go home. She is very slowly recovering from the pneumonia; it may take a month. However, the head CT showed that the low dose of the cancer drug is not being effective on the brain tumor; it has grown substantially. The CT also revealed a number of a type of small strokes called lacunar infarctions. (No, I’m not making that name up; my mom has brain farcts.) She is now on a 325 mg./day aspirin regimen to prevent more of them. There is nothing predictable about her situation, and that’s all there is to it.
My cousin: Longer time readers will recall that I am also caregiver for my husband’s cousin here in town, Marie. She is a brittle diabetic who has never taken care of herself as she should, and is now suffering all the consequences of it. Every system in her body is affected. She’s almost blind as a bat. She has virtually no feeling in her right foot, and only partial in her left. She has many vascular problems as the arterial system is both deteriorating due to the diabetes, and getting clogged from plaque due to poor diet and a near total lack of exercise because of severe arthritis in her hips, back, and neck. She has had some silent heart attacks. The vascular shutdown has led to her developing vascular dementia, the primary reason I had to take over her financial, legal and medical affairs. How she has pushed herself to do what she does to keep on going and to do things for herself, in spite of her extreme pain and near-constant exhaustion amazes me; I don’t think I could do it. She truly is a role model for me. Her son got out of a 20 year stretch in prison last year. She has spent the last 20 years living for this time, dreaming of what it was going to be like, but things have gone very badly. Her son has inherited not one of her traits of independence, of making do rather than asking for hand-outs, of being grateful for what you have, of integrity. She has seen all her dreams of the future blown to smithereens as she has realized that the son she has sacrificed for all these years is NOT the son she actually has.. Her health – physical, mental, and emotional – has deteriorated in the last 6 months in a nosedive, bringing extra visits to cardiologists, vascular surgeons, psychiatrists, physical therapists, CTs, MRIs, urgent care, as well as more frequent check-ups with her regular provider. She has had an incredibly hard life ALL her life – you’d never be willing to see a movie of it because it would be too intensely depressing! – and to now realize that the end of it is going to be just more of the same **** she’s dealt with for the entire memory of her existence…… it’s no wonder she is now dealing with severe anxiety and depression, in spite of her heart and soul love for Jesus. She is deeply appreciative of the love and care I and my family have shown her, but having never been loved before in all her life, she does not know how to receive it. Although WE consider her as part of our family, she always thinks of herself as an outsider.
Me: Trying to cross some rocks across a river last September, I took a fall. Didn’t go all the way down – caught myself on my hands going forward, but really did a twist. For most folks, it might have resulted in a few hours or a day or two of feeling a bit sore, but because of skeletal abnormalities I have, it really did a number on me. As usual, when I’ve had to stop because of an injury, when I did try to start again, it set off headaches, so I backed off and waited, then tried again, more headaches, waited , tried… and the wait between got longer and longer, and I couldn’t get past the headaches. Then the roller coaster ride of my mom’s and Marie’s situations started, and even attempting to exercise went out the window. My eating habits devolved to whatever was easiest to grab, because eating healthy takes time, energy and thought, none of which I had to spare. I had a lot of trouble sleeping, in spite of my meds. I felt like I was just a leaf in a river, going down rapids at that, with no control. But in March I finally started seeing a physical therapist, and though it’s very slow going because I’m not as faithful at doing my exercises as I should be, it IS improving. Last week I even did my treadmill three days. I’ve been doing a lot better at prepping veggies so they’re ready in my frig, so I’m eating better. I’ve even cooked actual meals a few times a week for the last month. My doctor figured out that the dose of thyroid I take had gotten too high for my body’s needs, and since we lowered it by a third, I am sleeping ever so much better.
The stress has certainly pushed my bipolar buttons and I have sometimes found myself close to the edge emotionally at home. But I always remember this: Once the appointments are done, I get to go home to my nice, normal life. Mama and Marie don’t. I’m not having to live with cancer like Mama. No matter what I may need to do for her, it will never be as hard as what she is going through, and what she has yet to go through, barring the unexpected gift of a sudden death from something else. Unlike Marie, I don’t have diabetes and arthritis and dementia and and and, so that all I have to look forward to is getting worse and worse and worse. None of my kids are breaking my heart. I don’t worry about any of them becoming homeless. I’m not lonely and isolated, unable to drive, with no hobbies and nothing to do but watch TV and hold my chinchillas. The same loving Father is with us all, and gives grace to us all, but I have to readily admit that I have the easier portion right now!
When people ask me what I’m up to these days, I often roll my eyes (and sometimes laugh) and tell them, “I don’t HAVE a life right now – I have other people’s lives.” To a great extent, it’s true – my life is taking care of THEIR lives. But in reality, my life isn’t my life anyway. The verse that keeps going through my head in the last months is from Psalm 31 “My times are in Your hands.”
Years ago, when my migraines and fibro were at their worst, and I felt terribly guilty about the weight my kids, especially Bethy, had to carry to make the household run, God made the point to me that what was happening in MY life was His will for THEIRS as well. (In the years since, He has shown me one impact my illnesses had on my kids: they all have a deeper level than usual of compassion and understanding for the hurting and the sick and the weak.) God’s purposes for events in our lives are never limited to just “us”; He has much broader things in mind. Much as my mom and Marie sometimes (ok, with Marie it’s ALL the time) feel guilty for the fact that they need my help, or for how much of my time their needs take, it’s not their choice – it’s God’s purpose for this time in their life, and His purpose for ME for this time in their life, too.
These times are sometimes stressful, sometimes exhausting, yes, but when I keep the perspective that my times are in HIS dayplanner, I know that I’ll get through – and be glad that I kept the appointment!
Recalculating
Posted on: February 8, 2014
I’ve only driven a few times using a GPS. It’s interesting being told what to do by this robot voice, “Left turn 100 yards”, “Merge into right lane”, “Continue straight at divide.” When you’re driving to someplace unfamiliar, there’s a certain comfort in knowing that SOMEONE (ok, someTHING) knows what the heck you’re supposed to be doing! It doesn’t even faze the gizmo if you take a wrong turn. It just calmly says, “Recalculating…. Recalculating…” and plots a new route to get you to your destination. (At least, you hope that’s where you end up…)
Back in October, my daughter was diagnosed with placenta previa, a condition which can lead to months of bed rest, at home or in the hospital, or premature delivery. Since she already has a 4 yo and 2 yo, either result would mean needing a good deal of help. So, I cleared my calendar of all engagements that I could for the foreseeable future so I would be available come what may.
Recalculating.
Then in November, a new ultrasound showed that as the uterus had been expanding, it had taken the placenta up the wall completely away from the cervix. All risk was now gone and she was kicked back to her mid-wife with an ok for the birthing center birth they had planned on.
Recalculating.
Then on December 5th, my mom was diagnosed with Stage IV lung cancer. The initial guesstimated timeline, just from seeing cancer cells in the fluid drained from the pleural sac, was 4-6 months. Imaging determined that Mama has a large tumor in her right lung, a small one in her temporal lobe in her brain, and bone cancer in two ribs and in her mid-spine. Yikes. That was worse than the first doctor even knew, leaving us to wonder if the estimate was too generous. The tumor in her lung caused the sac around her lung to fill with fluid at such a rate that we were taking her to the hospital to have a liter plus drained every 4 to 5 days. 4 – 6 months was looking generous.
Recalculating.
Then it was determined that she was a candidate for a targeted drug called Tarceva. (The biggest advancement in cancer treatment of the last few years is that they can test the cancer itself for certain genetic mutations that indicate specific vulnerabilities in the cancer. Drugs have been designed to exploit those vulnerabilities. It’s the difference between a sniper’s bullet and a bomb. Traditional chemo kills not only cancer cells, but healthy cells as well. Targeted drugs kill pretty much only cancer cells, and thus cause many fewer, and less toxic, side effects.) It wouldn’t be a cure. There IS no curing Stage IV lung cancer. (Not by man, I mean.) The cancer would, sooner or later, mutate around the drug, but it would buy Mama some time and a better quality of life for a while. The Tarceva began to take effect within days, reducing the fluid fill rate drastically. She began regaining energy and appetite, and had more days of feeling more like her old self. The timeline was extended to possibly as long as a year.
Recalculating.
The drug began causing a nasty side effect to the skin on her face, drying it out terribly, especially around her eyes, causing them the sting and burn horribly and constantly. Unbearable. The doctor lowered the dose, which helped a little, but the effect on her eyes was still too much. The dose was to be lowered again, and if it still caused the side effect, or if it didn’t cause the side effect but wasn’t effective against the cancer, Mama would just stop it and let things go their course.
Recalculating.
But Mama hasn’t started taking the lower dose yet. Last Sunday, two days before the supply of the lower dose arrived, she started having severe nausea and vomiting, a headache hitting suddenly then disappearing, and severe back pain, such that she ended up in the ER Tuesday night. Other than getting IV hydration, the trip was a bust and she went home feeling worse than when she went in. When she saw the oncologist on Wednesday, Dr. P said the symptoms indicate that the brain tumor hasn’t been affected by the Tarceva; it must have kept growing all this time. New drugs have been added to combat the nausea and the pain, and so far are doing very well. She is going to have a single, high dose of radiation on her ribs, the probable cause of her back pain, which should eliminate that issue. She has had another MRI on her head and we’ll learn next week what it showed of the tumor there.
If the symptoms are because the tumor is growing, she probably won’t attempt any treatment it, since brain radiation carries side effect risks about as bad as the tumor itself – and still wouldn’t be more than a stopgap measure. And she isn’t restarting the Tarceva, either, until we know what’s up with the brain tumor. There would be no point to keeping the lung cancer at bay to prolong her life while the brain cancer is working so hard to end it.
Recalculating. Recalculating.
Life is full of recalculating for all of us. We think we’ve got that new job all locked up… and then they hire someone else. We expect to be in the job we have until we retire… and we get pink-slipped. We’re finally getting ahead on saving some money… and the car breaks down. We’re just starting to set the nursery up for the new baby, choosing a name, figuring out how we’ll deal with time off work and juggling day care …. and Mama goes into labor 3 months early with preeclampsia. A tree lands through the roof. Of course, most recalculations aren’t as dramatic. We plan to go grocery shopping, but have to take the dog to the vet instead. Plan to spend the afternoon doing a blog post, and the computer crashes. (Yep, getting personal there.) Wake up with a migraine. Forgot to charge the phone, so it dies. Some days it just feels like life took a wrong turn, doesn’t it? Sometimes it seems we don’t go two blocks straight in a row before we’re hanging a left or ducking into an alley! Sometimes what we thought was a side street turns out to be a freeway on-ramp. Sometimes we find ourselves stuck in a parking lot
Recalculating.
Most folks driving with a GPS can recount times when theirs gave them a wrong direction. I’ve read stories of folks who’ve gotten into horrendous accidents by too blindly following their Garmin. You still have to use some common sense about using one. Just because the GPS says to turn left doesn’t mean we turn left if that means turning the wrong way on a one way street! No GPS is 100% reliable.
If we’re honest, I think many of us would have to admit that some of the time we harbor distrust of God that HE might not be altogether reliable, either. When our life direction takes what feels like a “wrong turn”, when we end up in a creepy canyon, a dreary desert, or a challenging cliff, we tend to question God’s purpose and intent. We question His guidance, His provision, His very goodness. Some of us, to our shame, are even suspicious of the pleasant paths – a winding, wooded drive, a picnic in the park, or a beautiful beach. We impugn God’s nature by wondering when the other shoe is going to drop, sure that the nice scenery is simply a sucker punch.
Starting with the 2 x4 upside the head on the Damascus road, Paul faced a LOT of recalculations in his life. It’s probably fair to say that few of us can match his resume. When writing to his dear friends at Philippi, he had this to say about it all: “I know how to abase and how to abound, how to be in plenty and in want.” It seems strange to think of “how to abound” or “how to be in plenty”. I mean, those things are easy to do, right? Let the good times roll! But Paul makes clear that the one situation is really no different than the other. Abasing or abounding, being in plenty or in want, both require the same response lest we be in danger of letting our situation define us, rather than the other way around. Paul could face any recalculation with equal equanimity because he had learned the ONE constant: “I can do all things through Christ Who gives me strength.” He knew Who was his GPS.
We should be “doing” the good times through Christ’s strength just as much as we “do” the hard times, because ALL times are equal tools in His hands for conforming us to His image. We should be as ready to accept from God’s hand pay raise or pay cut, health or illness, the fruition of the hopes we cherish – or the death of them. Not that we don’t honestly acknowledge the pain or difficulty of some situations, but that we don’t let that pain fool us into thinking that it’s greater than we can bear – greater, in fact, than God is. Nor do we let the pleasantness of some situations lull us into a false sense of security or promise, as if the fact that things are “good” now means they will continue so. “Good” times, “bad” times – all times are simply God times, to be gotten through focused on Him, not on the situation.
We would be fools to place implicit, complete trust in a man-made GPS. We are greater fools to place anything BUT implicit, complete trust in our God. No matter how many times the route of our life seems to be recalculating, we can rest quite assured that we ARE on our way to the correct destination, and that God knows just how to get us there.
Our GPS – God Positioning System – will never steer us wrong.
Good news of great joy
Posted on: December 22, 2013
It has been interesting to note the varying reactions I am receiving to the news that my mother has terminal cancer.
Some people find my own reaction a bit disconcerting. I cannot remember a time when I did not know quite certainly that my parents were not going to live forever. They never shied away from talking about their eventual deaths, and always made sure they had prepared the practical documents necessary – wills, funeral preferences, and so on. My dad dropped dead of a massive, unheralded heart attack 22 ½ years ago at the age of 68, in all other respects hale and hearty. Ever since that day, I have been even more aware of the certainty of my mom’s eventual death. As her age has crept up into her 80s, each year as I prepare my calendar and write down the birthdays, I have wondered if she would still be here when her next one rolled around. So the mere fact that my mother is dying isn’t earth-shattering to me.
The suddenness of it is a bit of a shock. The shortness of breath came on rapidly – over just a period of weeks, without her even quite paying attention to how bad it had gotten until she could no longer walk from room to room without huffing and puffing. Some people seem fixated on the fact that she’s always been so healthy, as if that should somehow preclude her getting sick. The fact that she’s never smoked makes getting lung cancer seem inconceivable to others. Neither of those factors makes me blink. Cancer – all types – is an equal opportunity disease, striking the healthy and the sick, the old, the young, and though certain types of cancer are more common from certain types of exposures, any cancer can show up in anyone, no matter how well they take care of themselves.
The reaction that I least can relate to, though, runs along the lines of, “What a bad time to get this kind of news! Sure must spoil the holidays for you.” “This Christmas must be so bittersweet for you!,” or even, “I guess you won’t be doing much for Christmas this year, will you?” (Note that I didn’t say I don’t understand those reactions, just that I don’t relate.)
“For behold! I bring you good news of great joy which shall be to all people!” In this season of Good News, getting the news that this is my mother’s last Christmas with us is NOT bad news. Christmas is not just about “little baby Jesus.” Christmas is just Act One of Easter! Jesus’ suffering for us began the day He emptied Himself of Heaven and took on the form of a man so that He could be a High Priest Who can fully sympathize with us in ALL we go through. In Jesus’ life, He lived every life. In His death, He died every death. There is nothing we go through of which He cannot say, “Nope. No idea what that’s like.” Getting the news of Mama’s cancer right now, in this season when we celebrate the birth of the One Who came to be our Savior keeps us focusing not on Mama’s coming death, but on HIS death and resurrection already accomplished, and His second advent yet to come.
There are advantages and disadvantages to the different modes of each of my parents’ death. It was a blessing not to watch my dad suffer, but it was hard not to get to say good-bye, hard not knowing those “lasts” that we were spending together. We will watch my mom dwindle, and there will probably be some suffering, and, yes, it will be hard, but at least getting the news now means we get to cherish this last Christmas together, making every opportunity count – not for HER so much as for us. Once she’s in Heaven with the Lord, those memories will pale in any significance compared to the joy of being in His presence, but for us, those memories will be dear and sweet to carry forward until our own times come to join her in that Church Triumphant.
There have been, and will be, tears during this season. Knowing this is our last together adds a poignancy to each decoration, each carol, each card. I know when I next get out my decorations, Mama won’t be here to see them. But as a Stephen Curtis Chapman song that I have always loved, but which now has even more meaning to me, says, she’s going to be Home for Christmas next year – and since when is going Home bad news? Sad for us who will be left behind awhile, yes. But not BAD.
Mama’s house is decorated to the nines just like always. It’s taken her all month to get things out, and she’s had to have some help with some things, but while she’s still living, nothing on earth could stop her from celebrating Christmas! The GOOD News has trumped and triumphed over any bad or sad news. Even in our sadness, we still have great joy! JOY TO THE WORLD! THE LORD HAS COME!
Check
Posted on: December 7, 2013
Most of those who know me know that I am a planner. I always have (at least one) Things to Do list going. If I am planning an event, I may have multiple lists. If we are planning a trip to see our kids across the state, I will set out a box a month, or even two, ahead of time so that as I think of things that need to go over to them, I can put those items in the box, knowing that they won’t then be forgotten.
Anyone who knows my mom knows where I got this trait from. Mama is an organizer par excellence. When we moved from Texas when I was 12, she packed every box herself, assigning each a letter and number, and keeping meticulous track of the contents of each. When we unloaded in Utah, each letter designation went to its assigned room, and by box number she knew exactly which boxes she needed to unpack in what order. (The designation I remember most was “NNI” – “not needed immediately”. You know, for those things you keep in the attic or storage closet. I’m not sure how many years it may have been before the last one of those got opened!)
Actually, though, we both got that trait from Someone Else. God’s a planner. I started reading again through the book of Joshua recently, going a paragraph a day, looking for something to really cogitate on. Early on, I hit the story about Rahab hiding the two Israelite spies, something jumped out at me.
Remember that the story had begun well over 40 years before. Recall the history of that journey: The ten plagues to convince Pharaoh to let them go, ending with the death of the firstborn sons. (That included adults as well as children, remember. How many of Pharaoh’s fighting men may have fallen in that harvest?) The parting of the Red Sea. The drowning of the Egyptian Army. The pillars of fire and cloud. The bitter waters turned sweet. Water from the rock. Manna from heaven! Miracle after miracle after miracle. God affirmed to them again and again that He was giving them the land He had promised to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. But when God told the people to go in to take the Promised Land, they didn’t trust Him. They said, “Unh-uh. No way, Jose. No can do.”
God wasn’t just pretending that He wanted them to go in and take the land. He meant it. But He didn’t abandon them because they disobeyed Him. Instead, He sent them on a 40 year detour until all those who had refused to trust Him had died, and the next generation would be ready to take up the challenge. That detour wasn’t God’s original intent, but what did those 40 years accomplish? God wasn’t just using them to mark time waiting for the older generation to die. He used the time to keep proving Himself faithful to that next generation, raising up a generation who would trust and obey His leading. Very importantly, though, He wasn’t just working in the Israelites. He also used that time to prepare the Israelites’ enemies in the Promised Land. During those 40 years of wandering, God was with the Israelites and gave them victory over other enemies outside of the Promised Land. They wiped out several kings of surrounding territories – not just beat them, but utterly destroyed them.
When Rahab hid the spies who came to Jericho, she told them her people had heard how the Lord had dried up the Red Sea and brought the Israelites up out of Egypt (which was over 40 years earlier, when she would have been but a small child, if even born yet.) She said they had heard what the Israelites had done to the neighboring kings. The people’s hearts had already melted away in fear because they knew the Lord had already given the land into the hands of the Israelites. (Although the Israelites weren’t looking for a word from an innkeeper of Jericho as a “fleece” from the Lord about whether or not to try to take the city, hearing her words about the quaking-in-their-boots status of the Jericho people had to have nevertheless been a very heartening extra affirmation to them that the outcome was already assured!)
One of the great “both/ands” of Scripture is God’s sovereignty and man’s choice. God is sovereign, yet He is no mere puppeteer, no programmer of automatons. Man chooses his actions, yet still cannot surprise God and upset his plans, forcing Him to formulate some “Eternal Plan B”. The Israelites SHOULD have gone up to take the land the first time He told them to. Yet even in their disobedience, He was preparing to use the consequences of their disobedience to bring about the victory for their children. Had the Israelites gone up when they first should have, they would have faced an entirely different cast of characters. The Israelites would have won, because God has promised so – but we’ll never know just precisely how it would have played out. (Or maybe God will show us the alternative ending in heaven?) Since the Israelites were disobedient, though, God raised up Rahab. He had her in just the right place at just the right time with just the right courage.
I can just see God ticking off items on His “To Do” list to set this whole scenario up – going back years and years and years before the events we read about. The same is true of our lives. The events we are going through now, the people we are encountering – things have been set in motion, wheels in wheels, for years and years, to bring things together at just this time, just this place.
I was acutely conscious of this over the last couple of days. You see, on Thursday I took my mother to see our family doctor, who sent her for a chest x-ray, then straight to the hospital. They removed 1.3 liters of fluid from her right lung. Further CT scans and study of the fluid drawn off have given a definitive diagnosis that my 84 year old mother has cancer. She will not seek treatment other than palliative care. The estimate is that she will not be with us past this summer.
All those technologies that were in play didn’t get created yesterday. They have been years and years in the making. All those people attending to Mama didn’t suddenly appear at the hospital yesterday. They’ve been training for years, practicing their profession for years. One of the nurses has been a nurse for 40 years. The oncologist is far from the start of his career. Wheels intersecting with wheels, all in motion for years and years to bring people and events together at just this time, just this place.
One of my earliest memories is a ride at Disneyland where you are going on a track through a cavernous building with no lights, and random figures suddenly light up and appear as you approach or pass. It is a vague memory, but it is terrifying. The randomness of the appearance of the figures gives such a helpless feeling of being at their mercy. It is just what I imagine it must be like to face a situation such as my mother and the rest of our family now face, if you believe that all things are simply random cosmic events, the product of a capricious, mindless, pointless universe.
I am so thankful that the universe is not that Disneyland ride! No, and again, NO. Satan is actively working for evil, and seeks all that is destructive, rejoicing in all pain and suffering – but God is greater, and no matter what Satan may machinate, always and ever God is the Master, and it is HIS plans that prevail to bring about HIS purposes. We do not need to – and should not expect to – understand what God’s specific purposes are. We already know His ultimate purpose: the good of those who love Him, which is to be conformed to the image of His Son. No matter how random events may seem, they are not, in fact, random. No matter how purposeless or pointless things may seem, they are, in fact, neither.
God has been planning for these moments Mama’s whole life. We have no idea how many boxes have already been checked off, but I am confident of this: not one item on God’s “To Do” list for her life will be left undone. On earth as it is in Heaven. Amen!
Last December, I got to see my niece sign in a Christmas cantata. That’s not a typo. I don’t mean “sing”. I mean SIGN. You see, Alyssa was completing a degree on her way to a career as an American Sign Language interpreter, and as part of her efforts, she volunteered to be part of a choir that signed the cantata while the regular choir sang it.
It has been fascinating to learn about ASL through Alyssa’s hands. Some signs have a traceable connection to their origin; for example, the sign for “woman” is reminiscent of the bonnet strings she would have worn in days gone by, “man” of the hat he would tip to the ladies. Others bear no particular connection to the word or concept they represent. There may even be multiple options for how to sign a particular word. Regions use “slang” signs for local cities. Someone from the Washington west coast visiting New York would have to spell out S-e-a-t-t-l-e rather than using the colloquial sign, and the same visitor wouldn’t recognize the New Yorker’s, ahem, “shorthand” for Brooklyn. Different countries have their own sign languages. If you haven’t been taught which signs mean what, you can go hilariously wide of the mark trying to guess their meaning.
Watching the sidelines at baseball games. Since the coach doesn’t want the other team to know what he’s telling the pitcher, he’ll perform a whole series of often comica- looking gestures. Sometimes he’s joined by another coach or a player likewise doing (other) gestures. The pitcher has been told which person to watch, and he knows which of the gestures actually mean something. To the rest of us, it’s just an amusing show that looks something like a coordination test – or something a cop has you do if he suspects your sobriety.
When fellowship with God was broken after Adam and Eve left the Garden, and man began creating his own religions, one of the most common elements involved reading “signs”, also called “omens”. Elaborate systems were developed for reading meaning into specific weather events, the entrails of sacrificed animals, bones thrown like dice. Perhaps three buzzards flying overhead meant “death is approaching”, while a dove in an apple tree meant “you’re sure to succeed in your venture”. The alignment of the stars, the appearance of meteors, eclipses – all were subject to interpretation as signs portending certain outcomes or in which guidance was to be found for determining one’s course of action. Such sign reading has remained a hallmark of human culture through all of history, sometimes done in earnest, sometimes with a laugh. (Broken any mirrors lately?) Such sign reading makes life kind of like following one of those diagnostic charts. “Do you have a fever? Yes – go on to next question. No – return to start.”
Before the Israelites entered Canaan, God gave them very blunt instructions about reading such “sign language”: Don’t. Period. Commands such as “There shall not be found among you anyone who … practices divination or tells fortunes or interprets omens … for whoever does these things is an abomination to the Lord” are repeated a number of times. Pretty strong language. Through Judges and the books of the Kings of Israel, you can see the results that followed when the people followed the words of the prophets of God and when they sought that of the prophets of anyone else.
Sadly, many Christians still do much the same kind of sign reading, only we “holy-fy” it by ascribing the “signs” to God. Something we want badly comes up on a good sale. Bingo! Must be a sign that God wants us to have it. We meet someone who seems to meet all our wish list for a desirable mate, so that must be a sign that God wants us to jump right into a relationship. A business opportunity lands in our lap. Must be a sign we’re supposed to do it. Or conversely, a door shuts. Must mean we’re not to go that direction.
Now, any and all of these may, in fact, be perfectly appropriate actions to take. He may want us to have the sale item. The person may be Mr./Miss Right. The business may be successful. But if we are simply interpreting opportunity as a “sign”, we are doing what God told Israel not to do. It’s dangerous! Remember when Jonah decided to run away from God? There was a ship waiting in the harbor and a favorable wind! What about that shut door? It may mean we should give up on that direction – or it may be that the Enemy is working and we should pray our way past Him, or maybe we’re just supposed to wait awhile before trying again.
But wait – according to Scripture, didn’t God use signs? He did, in two ways. In most cases, God originated a sign to confirm a promise or an announcement. The rainbow appeared and He told Noah that it was a sign of His covenant to never again flood the earth. The angel announced the Savior’s birth and said, “This shall be a sign unto you….” In other cases, He said, “When you see this sign happen, then this is what you are to do.” He gave the pillar of fire, and when it moved, the Israelites were to move; when it stayed put, they were to do the same. The crucial thing is that He directly or through His acknowledged prophets, told the people involved the sign and its significance either ahead of time or as it appeared. He never left it up to the people to interpret what a sign meant.
There are also other cases where God did not institute a sign, but honored a sincere request for guidance by giving one. God told Moses that He would give guidance through the “urim and thumim” that the priests were to wear, apparently something used akin to a consecrated coin flip. Jonathan is the best example of an individual asking for and receiving guidance. Notice that the terms of the sign were laid out ahead of time, and were expressed in unequivocal terms. If the enemy said to Jonathan, “We’ll come down to you”, Jon was to hightail it back to camp. If the enemy said, “Come on up!”? God was already holding up Jon’s hand and announcing, “And the winner of this round is ….”
If we have given appropriate prayer and thought to our ways, yet still find ourselves in a quandary, and so sincerely pray that He would give us guidance through our circumstances – as well as through other confirmations – then doors that shut or close, people that come into our lives, or outcomes of events may, indeed by given as signs, but such signs shouldn’t be our first resort or expectation. The majority of His leading in Scripture clearly came through direct guidance. Jesus said, “My sheep know my voice.” The more closely we walk with Him, the more familiar His voice becomes, and the easier it becomes to recognize and follow it.
If we do decide to ask for signs, then we need to keep certain things in mind.
When I was a child, I was fascinated by stories of unbelievers who had prayed for, and received, a sign that God was there. So, I would frequently sit on my bike by an intersection and say, “God, if You’re real, make the next car that passes a red one.” Not surprisingly, I never did get a red one! Not because God wasn’t there, but because I didn’t need that sign; I just wanted it for my own gratification so I could glory in having such a cool story to tell. God is under no obligation to give us a sign simply because we ask for one – either in a case like this, or to avoid having to really work through a decision.
If we pray for a sign to choose between two options, we better be sure we’ve been right to narrow it to those two in the first place. If He’s trying to tell us “Africa”, but we ask for Him to give us a sign to choose between “Mexico” and “Thailand”, we aren’t likely to get a good answer.
Signs aren’t for things that God has already made clear. If we ask for a sign regarding something God has already spoken on, essentially asking “Did You really say…?”, we risk getting an answer from someone other than God. More than a few believers have asked for a sign that their sin was ok – and got it. Adultery? Living together without marriage? Stealing? False religions? I’ve heard stories of signs of all kinds supposedly given by God to affirm that He approved of things that clearly, completely, and unequivocally violate His Word.
It’s also easy to pray for a sign, and then, if the answer turns out to not fit with what we think the answer should have been, to decide to ignore or reinterpret the answer. I always think of a scene I happened to catch from a movie years ago as I was channel surfing. A guy’s wife had died, and he had vowed to never marry again. Then he meets this knockout. So he goes and stands in front of his dead wife’s portrait and says, “Honey, I know I said I’d never marry another, but you know, I’ve met this amazing woman and I really want to spend the rest of my life with her, since you’re gone. But I need to know that you’re ok with it, so please, give me some kind of sign. Any little thing.” He continues on in that vein all through what is to come. As soon as he first mentions a sign, the lights flicker. Then clocks chime wildly. The portrait begins to spin. Then doors and windows fly open. A wind begins to blow, first floofing his hair and setting the potted plants dancing, then growing in strength until the it’s absolutely howling, the furniture is flying and the guy is holding on to the door frame to keep from being blown away. It all dies down with the house a wreck, and it’s quiet again – and the guy is still carrying on, “Just any little sign. No matter how small. I’ll be watching.” The scene is tragically funny – but it’s not funny to watch a believer (or even a whole church) act the same thing out. If we ask for a sign, we better be serious about honoring the answer. The Pharisees said they wanted a sign so that they could believe, but in fact, there was no sign that God could give them that would have convinced them. There were plenty of signs available; they chose not to see.
If I try to read Alyssa’s hands without her telling me what she’s saying, I end up giving her a good laugh, but there’s no harm done. If we don’t follow the Biblical precedents for signs, and attempt to read God like non-believers read signs of “fate”, we risk potentially serious consequences.
We may look for God in the signs of the earthquake and the whirlwind – the world certainly does – but only we believers have the privilege of hearing His still, small voice. Let’s take full advantage of that guidance!
Slip Slidin’ Away
Posted on: October 14, 2013
Imagine you are driving on a very, very wet freeway going 60 miles an hour, with traffic in every lane ahead, behind and beside you. Suddenly you realize you are hydroplaning – your tires no longer in direct contact with the pavement, but instead floating on a cushion of compressed liquid. You may need to stop – but find you can’t. You may want to turn – but instead find yourself launching off the road. You may want to go straight – but instead find yourself spinning ‘round and ‘round. Until and unless your tires reconnect with the pavement, you are at the mercy of the laws of physics, utterly helpless. If your tires have good tread, you may gain traction again fairly soon. But if your tires are bald….. Welcome to the world of bipolar.
Although I have mentioned a number of times in this blog that I have Bipolar 2, I’ve never talked about precisely what it is, or what it is like for me to live with it. However, since my diagnosis happened three years ago today, this seems a good day to talk about it.
My BP2 first evidenced itself in high school, but went unrecognized. I was diagnosed manic-depressive by a psychologist at college, but after a few sessions to give me some coping strategies, I was sent on my way, and I thought I was “all better now.” But although the particular presenting symptoms changed over time, I continued to struggle with what I felt was a monster inside me for over 30 years before being diagnosed and put on medication. (Although the usual expectation is that it may take 18-36 months trying half a dozen or more meds before finding one that works well with the fewest side effects, it took only 6 months and the 3rd med I tried before we hit on a success that not only works very well but has no apparent side effects for me – for which I am exceedingly thankful!) With my medication, things are very different now, but although the meds help, they don’t cure. I will ALWAYS, short of a divine intervention, have BP2. Meds put some tread on my tires, but it’s the difference between bald and barely legal. And the pavement is always going to be wet; it’s just a matter of how deep the water is. Skidding at any moment will always remain a real possibility.
Bipolar – BP – like most mental illness is a brain disorder that causes certain areas of the brain to become hyperactive, while others become under-active. Why it happens is not known, although there is some genetic predisposition involved. Bipolar is broken down into 2 levels. Type 1 is the more commonly known version, and what most people think of when they hear the term bipolar; it is this version that ends up with patients doing horrific things that make headlines, although it is only a very, very small percentage of BP1 patients who commit such acts. BP2 is a milder version that doesn’t go to the extremes BP1 does, a difference of scale rather than substance. Like most mental illness, much of what either version goes through is not unlike what is known by the rest of humanity, but it is exaggerated far beyond the normal experience – far beyond what the normal coping mechanisms can deal with. (Just as cancer takes a normal process, the growth of cells, and sends it wildly out of control with no “off” switch.) One analogy for BP is to picture it like waves on an oscilloscope. “Normal” (i.e. non-mentally-ill) folks have waves that go up and down, but they fluctuate only so far from the baseline norm. The waves of a person with BP1 go way, way, way up and way, way, way down – from manic highs where she may not sleep for days, to suicidal depression. The swings may take months, or moments. For those of us with BP2, our symptoms and sufferings are the same as BP1 except that our waves don’t go all the way as high up or all the way as low down. Our highs are exhilarating, but not manic, and although we may have periods of deep depression and even suicidal thoughts, we are not nearly as much at risk for actual suicide. We generally tend to have more periods of relatively normal behavior than a BP1 as well.
For normal people, moods tend to be influenced heavily by life circumstances (and influenced by personality, of course.) If you have BP? Forget it. You’re stuck with the mood swing gumball machine – “oooo, what mood did you get today?” For some with BP, the swings happen slowly, and the stay in a mood may last months or even years; for others, the swings are mercurial. The causation of our moods may have little or no correlation with our life circumstances, but our moods have an overwhelming influence on our perspective on those circumstances. We don’t need anything to be depressed “about”; but when we’re depressed, as in any other depression, everything in our life will be a cause for despair because that will be the lens our brain is looking through. Highs are just as unrelated to life as are our lows, but when we’re up, then EVERYthing is wonderful and beautiful and we can do anything. (Although highs are exhilarating and can, admittedly, be rather fun, and bring on periods of tremendous creativity and inspiration, they are just as much a problem as lows because they are still warping our perception of reality.)
But mood swings are only a part of the package. They’re the most obvious, and certainly the symptom most likely for even a layperson to identify, but there’s much more to BP. The area of the brain that is involved affects other aspects of thinking and emotions. Although the precise constellation of symptoms will be different in every patient, they tend to be differing expressions of things that are common among us.
The BP brain has difficulties with impulse control. It is common for BP patients to be in constant financial trouble because they cannot resist buying anything they see that they want. Substance abuse of all kinds is common, as are gambling and risk-taking adrenaline rush activities. Many BPs are sexually promiscuous – even those who find it morally repugnant. We may tend to say inappropriate things, since the filter agent in our brains isn’t working.
The BP brain may fire thoughts and impulses that are weird at best, if not downright disturbing. Thoughts of self-harming are common. I don’t mean like those who deliberately hurt themselves as a physical expression of emotional pain, but simply as in random thoughts like wondering, as one is chopping up an onion, “What would it feel like if I put my fingers under the knife?” Driving down the freeway, one may find oneself thinking, “What if I ran into that concrete barrier?” Part of why I have an extreme aversion to standing on the edge of cliffs or on bridges is because I fight with the impulse to throw things off – my glasses, my camera, my purse. The baby in my arms. If you don’t understand BP, it’s easy to think that these thoughts arise out of some kind of subconscious desire to do harm, or a latent intent to do evil, but they don’t. They come because our brain is broken and synapses fire in odd ways. It’s that simple. Only an exceedingly small minority of us with BP will ever act on any of those thoughts. (For the record, I’ve never thrown actually anything off a cliff or bridge.) It is as disturbing to us to have these thoughts as it is to you to think about having such thoughts.
In sleep, the brain sometimes gets even worse. In our dreams, we may DO those things that are mere impulses we can dismiss in the day. (This next is the hardest for me to write, but it was one of the greatest reliefs when I found out it was BP-related; there may be someone reading this who needs to know it, too.) It’s not uncommon to have dreams that violate every moral value you hold and leave you blushing and humiliated and that may make it hard to interact with someone the next day while your brain is trying to sort out what was dream from what is reality. You KNOW that the other person has no idea what you dreamt, but, still… If you’re embarrassed to read that, think of how embarrassing it is to have those dreams – and how easy it is, if you don’t understand BP, to think of yourself as somehow evil and dirty for having such dreams, as if they arise from some subconscious desire. But again, it’s a broken brain, not a moral failing.
The BP brain tends to fixate, like being on a hamster wheel: once you get going on a particular thought track, it can be virtually impossible for you to get off that wheel. You may succeed in distracting yourself for a time while you do some task – making dinner, planning shopping, reading a book – but as soon as you are no longer engaged in that other, BAM! You’re right back on that hamster wheel as if you’d never left. Hurts, frustrations, problems at home or work or church – anything and everything is a potential hamster wheel. When we sound like a broken record going on and on about the same issue, we generally don’t even recognize that we’re doing it; it’s just giving voice to what we’re always going over and over and over in our own head. (This was one of the most blessed reliefs of going on my med – being freed from that hamster wheel!)
Our brain also tends to escalate. We get impassioned on a subject, and the more we talk or think about it, the more impassioned we get. Combined with the impulse control problem, we may tend to speak out much more strongly than we might at a calmer moment. We get agitated so that we cannot think rationally, or hear reason. We go in the tank and may not even realize we’re there. Anger is a major problem. As a friend of mine put it, we can “go from zero to b**** in 5 seconds or less.” Our brain is a minefield set with a hair trigger, and we do not always know what’s going to set it off. Thinking back later, we may be just as surprised as the person who set us off. (My meds help a lot here, too, but I still have to plead “guilty” on some counts!)
If you have BP and you’re aware enough to recognize your problems to any extent (which many or most BPs aren’t), because it’s a mental thing you may fall into the trap of thinking that somehow you “should” be able to think your way out of it, or pray your way out of it, or just try harder. Sadly, it just doesn’t work that way. That’s like a diabetic thinking they can will (or pray) themselves into making insulin. If your tires are bald, it doesn’t matter if your engine is tuned and you have plenty of gas. You still won’t have traction.
So, what do I think would be most helpful for me – and probably others with BP?
First and foremost, remember that while our BP affects us, limits us, and to varying degrees controls us, it is not US. We are more than our emotions, our moods, our behavior, our bipolar. We are more than our disease, just as a person with cancer is more than their cancer. For those of us who are believers, who we are is IN CHRIST. Our spirits remain intact and whole in Him, no matter what our cognitive mind and outward behavior may manifest. He holds us securely when we cannot hold onto Him.
Also of great importance: Validate our condition for what it is – a physiologically caused mental disease -not a lack of willpower, a failure of character, or a weakness of faith. As I’ve described already, it’s easy to feel as if we “should” be able to do better if we could just figure out how to try hard enough. It’s easy to feel like a moral failure, or like a “bad” Christian. If you hear us say anything like that, speak Truth against the lie. Speak words of worth and grace to us. If we’re down, encourage us with God’s faithfulness and gently remind us that we are wearing “Eeyore glasses” that won’t stay on forever. Don’t be surprised or hurt if we reject it or argue about it, as we probably will. If we’re on a high, don’t see it as a sign that we are “better” or that we are “making progress”, but instead caution us not to trust it, encourage us with God’s faithfulness, and gently remind us that our “rose-colored glasses” will crack sooner or later. And don’t be surprised or hurt if we reject it or argue about it, as we probably will. Always remember that our spirit is still listening, no matter how our cognitive mind and emotions may react! I can’t tell you how many times certain of my friends listened to my repetitions of my woes during my son’s Hell years, and responded consistently with gentle, positive encouragement that, at the time, I rejected – yet it made a huge difference once I was able to calm down later.
Don’t patronize us or dismiss us when we’re upset about something. Just because we’re BP doesn’t mean there might not be a very valid reason for us to be upset. Non-BP people get upset, too. The fact that our response may be over the top doesn’t automatically negate the validity of the reason we’re upset in the first place. Even if you don’t think the reason is valid, even if it comes because our BP brain is seeing something askew, acknowledge the reality that we are upset.
Don’t demean our BP by casually flinging the term about at people who are just moody, or get angry easily, or don’t deal well with stress.
Don’t take personally the accusations a BP brain may come up with. Since the BP brain is looking through a warped lens, it cannot judge rationally. Accept that the accusation is our brain’s reality at the moment, and try not to react with your own anger or with defensiveness. The real us does know better, even if our cognitive mind doesn’t. Try to respond emotionally to the real us while dealing rationally with the BP us.
Does being a BP mean we should get a free pass on behaving abominably? “She’s BP, so you just have to excuse her smashing up your car with a baseball bat.” Um, no. When we’re in the tank we need you to understand, yes, but that doesn’t mean you have to just stand by and let us do damage. If things are just too intense, and you need to protect yourself, then say, “I think my being here isn’t helping, so I’m going to leave now. We can talk more later.” We each have our limits of how much toxicity we can take; it is nothing to feel bad about if you simply can’t handle someone’s BP episodes.
You can help empower us by helping us figure out what we can and can’t exercise control over. It’s easy to feel totally helpless, but there may, in fact, be some factors we CAN do something about, or some triggers we COULD avoid. Just as there may be certain signs that a diabetic is getting low on blood sugar, there are sometimes certain “tells” that indicate something is brewing with a BP. Just as certain flashing lights may trigger an epileptic seizure, there may be situations that tend to trigger BP episodes. We just generally can’t recognize them ourselves, though, so it may be helpful if you point them out. I know one of my “tells”, and often cues me in to the fact that I’m feeling stressed long before I would become cognitively aware that “Oh, this is very stressful.”
One thing I’ve struggled with is that I usually can’t tell when I’m getting too worked up talking about a subject I’m upset about. If someone just listens and says nothing, it actually tends to escalate me as I try to get a response. Now that I’m on meds It helps for someone to ask, “Are you sure it’s worth getting this upset about?” or “OK, you’ve explained the problem. What do you think you could do about it?”
One of the biggest problems for most BP patients is that they won’t stay on their meds. I am in the small minority who are self-aware enough to recognize that it is only my meds that enable me to function as I do now. Most BP patients, once they get feeling better, decide that they no longer need their meds and stop taking them, with predictable results. If you know someone with BP and are in a position of enough trust, don’t let meds be a taboo subject. Meds are like an artificial leg for an amputee – you can walk as long as you’re wearing it, but it doesn’t make your leg grow back. Our meds don’t “fix” our broken brain, they simply enable it to function more like a healthy brain. There is no cure for BP.
My greatest fear now is that of my medication losing its effectiveness. That is unfortunately the way of psychotropic drugs; the brain gets used to them eventually. I may be able to stay on this drug, and even at this dose, for years. I may need to up the dose; I am at a mid-level dose now, so there are two more steps up I could increase to. Once that threshold is crossed, however, which will happen sooner or later, I will be back to playing medication roulette. There is no way of predicting how any person will respond to any particular medication. There is no one medication that is the preferred “first line of defense”. It truly is trial-and-error, and those errors can be pretty terrifying. The second drug I tried shattered me to pieces; if not for God’s grace, some of which came in the shape of a couple of dear friends, I’m not sure I’d have made it through the experiment. If I have to play the game again, I know God will be with me – but I will freely confess that I am still afraid of going to that dark place again.
When I received the diagnosis of BP2, it was world changing, like shifting a kaleidoscope and getting an entirely new picture. I can’t describe what a relief it was to have a name and explanation put to that monster in me. I wasn’t a terrible person, a bad, angry mother – I was a person with a broken brain. I wasn’t guilty so much as I was a victim. I hadn’t been deliberately slamming my car into others; I was hydroplaning. I know – ok, I suspect – that I have lost some friends over the years because of my BP. (Or maybe they just didn’t like puns.) Especially in the last 10 years before the diagnosis, I was very, um, intense, shall we say, and it’s not really surprising that some people pulled away. What amazes me, what I am so very, very thankful for, are the friends who stuck with me in spite of it all, who never saw me the way I saw myself. They have truly been ministers of God’s grace in my life – and BP or no BP, I hope that I may also extend that same grace to others.
So, there you have it, if you’ve actually read through this whole ridiculously long post! If this helps even one person to understand the world of BP better, elicits compassion from just one person for the BP in his life, helps one BP to feel like she’s not alone, then it’s been worth writing. God’s grace to you all, and to God be the glory.
Are We Doxies or Danes?
Posted on: October 3, 2013
Anyone who’s been around me long knows that I hold the dachshund to be the ultimately desirable dog. I had one growing up, and, please God, will have another before I die. There’s just something terribly cute about those short little legs on that looooong body, those big, floppy ears, and all that loose skin. That shape and loose skin aren’t just cute, though – they’re utilitarian. You see, doxies were bred for going after badgers. It’s easy to see how a doxie’s shape is ideal for going into tunnels, and with all that loose skin, even if a badger bit, it likely wouldn’t get much more than a mouthful of skin.
Waaaay back when I was a kid, Disney made a movie called “The Ugly Dachsund.” I loved it as a child, and was delighted to introduce it to my kids. Now that they’re grown, they still love it, and I expect my grandkids will one day share our laughter. The plot revolves around a Great Dane who, as the runt of the litter, is rejected by his own mother, but is then accepted by a doxie mom into HER litter. Believing himself, then, to BE a doxie, as he grows, he behaves like doxie siblings. You can see it coming, of course. When a Dane does the same thing a doxie does, the outcome is disaster. Run under a chair? Hide under a table? Squeeze through a tight spot? Crash, boom, thud! Not until the Dane goes through training to be in a dog show, and runs into a female Dane there, does he throw off his doxie-doodling, realize his true identity, and go on to fulfill every inch of his Dane grandeur.
It is funny to watch the mayhem, but there is also something poignantly pathetic about that poor Dane crawling on his belly, trying to go under things when he could easily step over them. As long as he identified himself as a dachshund, though, what else would you expect? If you’re a doxie, you can only do what doxies do. If you’re a Dane, you do what Danes do. It’s that simple. What you think you are will determine a lot of what you do.
I’ve struggled with this issue of mistaken identity. For many, many years I thought of myself as “just the mom” – that what I wanted didn’t really matter, that what I said didn’t really matter, that I didn’t really matter. And I acted accordingly. When I finally sought counseling (and got on my bipolar meds), I finally changed my identity from “just the mom” to “I am THE mom.” I started learning how to act on that identity, and to expect others to respect that identity. I stopped being a victim and began acting in the confidence of who I really am.
The last several months, I’ve been thinking about this concept in the spiritual arena. Who are we?
All my life, I have been taught and have believed that Christians are “saintsandsinners”. This perspective teaches that it’s a dual package, that we are just as much the one as the other. Maybe even more the latter than the former, because always – ALWAYS – the emphasis is on thinking of ourselves as (to borrow a phrase from a kids’ book) “terrible, horrible, no-good, very bad” sinners. Vile, filthy worms. We are SAVED, yes. We are FORGIVEN, yes. But ever and always we are to be contemplating on how far short we fall of reaching God’s best. There seems to be a fear that if we don’t focus on how bad we are, we will somehow start taking grace for granted.
I’ve been looking at what Jesus said in the Gospels, what Paul says in his letters, what the other writers in the New Testament have to say, and interestingly enough I find that I DON’T find that “saintsandsinners” language or perspective in it. Throughout the New Testament, “saints” and “sinners” are referred to as two entirely different identities. (There are only three references that might, depending on interpretation, use both.) All of the N.T. writers speak of an “us” and a “them”. Saints are those who have confessed Christ as Lord; sinners are those who are enemies of Christ. Saints are those who walk according to the Spirit; sinners are those who walk according to the flesh. Saints are those for whom there is no condemnation; sinners are those on whom God’s wrath still abides. Saints are the children of Light; sinners are children of darkness. Again and again, Paul emphasizes the new birth, that we are “new creations”. There’s no split personality about who we are in Christ as far as the writers of the New Testament are concerned. Believers are saints, not sinners.
Now, I can hear the gasps of “BUT WE STILL SIN!” Yes, we do. How many of you at this very moment are quoting 1 John “If we say we have no sin, the Truth is not in us….”? Note exactly what he says though. He doesn’t say, “If we say we are not sinners…” To quote a new book out by my dear college prof, Roger Mohrlang (Paul and His Life-Transforming Theology, available from amazon), “There is a world of difference between thinking of oneself as fundamentally still a sinner who may occasionally do good, and thinking of oneself as God’s renewed holy person who may occasionally do wrong.” If we think we’re a doxie, we’ll expect to do what doxies do. If we think we’re a Dane, we’ll know we can do differently.
The most commonly quoted passage to defend the position that we are doomed to remain sinners is Romans 7. If we accept Romans 7 as the normative description of the life of a Christian – no matter how much we want to do right, we’ll do wrong, and no matter how much we don’t want to do wrong, we’ll do it – then we will think of ourselves primarily and fundamentally as sinners, and sinning will be what we expect to end up doing. How could we help it? Sinners sin. Yet if this were the case – that we are just saved-but-still-sinners – then how could God seriously ask – no, expect – of us what He does? Is Paul telling us to “be kind to one another, tender-hearted, forgiving one another… (but good luck with that. It’s actually hopeless. You’ll never be able to do it.)”? “Put on the whole armor of God….. (You’ll undoubtedly lace up your boots the wrong way and hold your shield upside down, and be carried off on a stretcher, but hey, go for it anyway.)”? Is John really saying “Little children, I write this that you may not sin….. (yeah, right, as if you could help it.)”? If we are still fundamentally sinners, then God must have given us those instructions, not expecting us to actually DO them, but simply to keep us in a constant state of feeling incapable, incompetent, and incorrigible.
However, not all scholars DO accept Romans 7 as the normative description of the Christian life. Rather, they read Romans 7 as tied to the previous two chapters on attempting to find grace through the Law, and see it as the description of Paul’s life in the flesh as he tried to live life righteously under the Law. The final verse of chapter 7, and moving into chapter 8, then, mark a complete shift in identity as Paul describes life in the Spirit. If we think of ourselves fundamentally as saints, as new creations, then we should recognize that we have the power of the Spirit working in us. If we walk by the Spirit and not by the flesh, we have the power to DO those things He told us to do. Instead of expecting to do wrong, we recognize that we can choose to do the right at any given moment. The same grace that saved us by imputing God’s righteousness to us is the same grace by which we should be living out the new life of righteousness.
Again, it’s not that we may not still sin. As long as we live on this broken earth, we will face temptation because our flesh is still weak. But sin is now a choice, not our inevitable lot. The more we are walking in the Spirit, the more we will be putting to death the deeds of the body. The more we are keeping in step with the Spirit, the less provision we will be making for the flesh. The more we identify ourselves as saints, the more we will be conscious of desiring, by the Spirit’s power, to live out that identity. We can (and should) expect, by the power of the Spirit, to see ourselves being ever more and more conformed to the image of the Son. We remain always conscious of the state from which we were saved. We remain aware of the sins we still commit, and repent of them, grateful for God’s ever abundant grace which He has already granted us in the finished work of Christ Jesus. But we should not confuse our sin as an identity of being sinners.
We are not adopted children with a hyphenated last name, still bearing the surname of the old life along with our new one. We are not sinner-saints. We are saints. May we live that identity!
P.S. If you disagree with my columns, please leave comments. I welcome discussion of ideas, and believe that people can disagree without it being personal. I write to explore the mixed-up solution of my own thoughts, and I make no claim to perfect understanding, to having a “lock” on the truth, or that mine is the Only Right Perspective. Thank you.
Caveats and Mea Culpas
Posted on: August 23, 2013
Every time I publish a post, I am aware that there will be those who disagree with what I say. My last post, “Catechism vs. Christ”, caused some deep offence to some of the people close to me. (For which reason I pulled it within days of posting.) I have debated on whether to respond privately or publicly, but have decided that since the original offence took place in the public arena, so, too, should be the response, on the assumption (as any teacher will tell you) that if one person asks a question, ten are waiting to hear the answer. So, I am following up with some clarifications and a few mea culpas. Hoping that I don’t end up in even more trouble by trying to explain things better, here goes…
First, my title – “Catechism or Christ” – was poorly chosen. No question. As I often do, I titled the piece after I had written the post, to reflect off the closing line, so I was looking at the title through the eyes of what I had said (or intended, at any rate) in the post, and did not give sufficient thought to how the title would read on its own without context. 1) I was using the term catechism in its generic sense of “an exposition of doctrine”, not as a specific reference to any particular catechism (so named, or so in function) used by any particular denomination. 2) I also did not give adequate consideration to the fact that without the context of the entire piece, the title reads as if the two – catechism (doctrine) and Christ – are in opposition to each other. My intention was to refer to the empty situation of knowing all the details of the former, yet not actually knowing the Christ of whom such an exposition speaks – not to imply that the two are in opposition to one another, or that it is not possible to learn of the latter by means of the former.
I wrote the post to explain why I have ended up attending a Covenant church after growing up Southern Baptist and then spending 25 years as a Missouri Synod Lutheran. For the entire time I was a Lutheran, the subject of the declining numbers in the church was a frequent subject of angst, with much speculation on why folks were leaving. As I know much of my story is similar to that of many others now in Covenant, I thought it would be better – even helpful – for those I have left behind to know the reasons so there need be no conjecture about it.
I related how, coming from an intellectual and academic bent, I had come to realize that I tend to fall into the trap of focusing on knowledge itself rather than on the Christ Who should be the object and point of all learning. Knowledge should be a means to an end – Christ – not an end in itself. Some apparently read what I said as denying Christian scholarship altogether. I was writing of my own state of mind, not making any sweeping statement about Christian scholarship in general. What I said was that for ME, I have realized that the pursuit of the intellectual is a temptation to be puffed up. Of COURSE there are true Christian scholars whose gift and calling is to pursue Christ through the study of Scripture, theology, doctrine and then use their knowledge to build up the Church.
When I stated in my post that I did not find the focus of the churches I’ve been in to be on knowledge for the sake of knowing Christ better and becoming like Him, I was not saying or nor intending to imply that NO ONE ELSE could find Christ and being like Him as the focus at those churches. I just said that I didn’t. (The same sermon that my dh enjoys may leave me cold – and the sermons I get the most out of, he may have a million criticisms of. The church one person finds warm and welcoming another feels is cold and uninviting.) Nor was my statement aimed at any one specific church or denomination; as I said in the intro to the original post, I have attended MULTIPLE churches in my life.
On these points, I am grieved that what I said was taken in any way other than what I intended, and sincerely apologize for not being sufficiently clear in my wording.
On the second thread of my post, I have only one mea culpa. I do apologize for one of the statements I made that was a rather sweeping and harsh imputation regarding how some of us judge other Christians who don’t view things the way we do. I let myself get carried away and forgot to get that edited before posting. There is no excuse for it.
Beyond that, however, I continue to hold to what I said regarding issues aside from basic Christian orthodoxy. Being convinced of one particular interpretation over another isn’t the problem. Gathering together in like-minded groups isn’t necessarily a problem, either. The problem is that although thousands of theologians working from the same texts have not been able to agree, many denominations continue to insist that their, and only their, interpretation is The Only Possible Right One. They then use that position to fence off their little section of God’s pasture in a modern version of the old Corinthian game of “I am of Peter.” “I am of Apollos.” “I am of Paul.” “Well, I’m of Jesus – so there!” This denominational territorialism cannot be considered as making every – if any – effort to preserve any kind of unity in our one Lord. One of the things that draws me to the Covenant church is that it loves beyond its denominational doors in a way no other church I have been at has done, and actively works to support other churches, not just its own. Their focus is on the faith that unites all believers, not the definitions that divide us.
Again, I am sorry for offence I gave in my first post because of insufficiently clear writing. For offence because I hold the opinions I do, there is no remedy, I’m afraid.